makoyi: (Default)
Title: The Maenad of the Maquis
Author: [archiveofourown.org profile] rthstewart
Fandom: Narnia
Genre: romance, WWII
Pairing: Peter/OFC
Length: Medium (15,864 Words)

Author's Summary:
"He who loves not wine, women and song remains a fool his whole life long." Former High King of Narnia and current RAF Flight Officer Peter Pevensie is not a fool. Written for the 2010 Narnia Fic Exchange.

Review:
Another fic by a top author in Narnia fandom. Great as a WWII romance too, though knowledge of The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is probably required to understand Peter's background.

The Maenad of the Maquis (on AO3)
makoyi: (Default)
Title: The Shadows Feel Like Home (National Service series)
Author: [archiveofourown.org profile] burntcopper 
Fandom: Chronicles of Narnia, Torchwood, Good Omens
Genre: Post-series, War, Dark, Crossover, Spies
Length: Long (Words: ~52k)
Warnings: Violence

Author's Summary:
In which the Pevensies trip, fall, and somehow end up in Torchwood. It's not Susan's fault she shot an alien that was trying to kill Jack Harkness.



(Note: this is the sixth fic in a series which, though it has its own story arc separate from those, does require some knowledge of the character of the Pevensies in those other fics so do read those first.  They're rec'd in their own post here because the two story arcs are very different)

Review:
Just as in the other fics of this series, the characterizations are fantastic and, at times, deliciously chilling.  This one doesn't highlight their competence quite like the arc before, and chooses to focus primarily on action rather than character though if you were left wanting more Susan and Lucy from fics 1-5, this one gives the girls their chance to shine.  This fic specifically is a great crossover (mainly Torchwood) that manages to keep me engaged and guessing even though I know all the canons involved.

National Service (on AO3)
makoyi: (Default)
Title:  No Reservations: Narnia
Autho
r: [archiveofourown.org profile] Edonohana 
Fandom:
Narnia, No Reservations, RPF
Genre:
  General, Crossover, Meta
Length: Short (Words: 6,228)
note: rec'd on fancake

Author's Summary:
I’m crammed into a burrow so small that my knees are up around my ears and the boom mike keeps slamming into my head, inhaling the potent scent of toffee-apple brandy and trying to drink a talking mouse under the table.

Review:
Anthony Bourdain meets Reepicheep!  I can't believe I haven't rec'd this one yet.  It sounds so crack-y but it's not.  It's well done as a story and it actually has something kind of profound to say.  This story is about a real travel show going to a perfect place but it's not quite what you might expect.  Because what they find isn't a predictably Narnia-esque discovery about goodness and faith as beauty (which would never work with a No Reservations crossover).  But nor is it, as in many deconstructions of perfection, that it's a place where surface perfection hides an ugly truth. 

They find, as so often happens in No Reservations, that traveling somewhere fantastic is seldom everything you'd imagined, but that doesn't make it any less perfect or less beautiful and that encountering new cultures is a journey of self-discovery but a relativistic one with meaningful uncertainty and bigger questions rather than the obvious answers of a life lived unchallenged.  And when it comes to Narnia specifically, they find that there is a strange power to perfect even if its not what they imagined perfect would be.  And in a weird way, I think that combination really speaks about a kind of faith independent of religion.  It's a faith that CS Lewis probably wouldn't recognize as such, but still.  And it does it without talking about faith at all, but by talking about Narnia.

And I'm not sure that message could have been told quite so well or quite so profoundly (and especially not so efficiently - this is less than 7k words, remember) without using Narnia's allegory and No Reservations' template of (paradoxically) ambiguous discovery as a medium - which I think represents the pinnacle of fanfiction.

Now, I don't actually know if Edonohana set out to write a profound commentary on faith and the clash of imagined ideals and reality.  It's entirely possible they just thought it would make for a funny story - and it is funny and it has beautiful descriptions for people and places and food (that amazingly manage to stand in pretty effectively for the missing visuals of No Reservations) too.  The Anthony Bourdain voice is incredible and just perfectly nails both the snarky irreverence and the relativistic acceptance of canon... which is a little trippy beside the allegorical fantasy world of Narnia.  Maybe I'm reading into this things that aren't actually there.  But that in itself sounds a lot like a line out of No Reservations, so maybe there's something to it after all.

No Reservations: Narnia (on AO3)
podfic available (on AO3) - though frankly the author got Anthony Bourdain's voice so spot on that I really recommend reading it because part of the magic of the crossover is how easy it is to hear him narrate it

Now with cover art:


makoyi: (Default)
Title:  Lives by Breaking
Autho
r: Lady Sarai
Fandom:
Narnia
Genre:
  General
Length: Very Short

Author's Summary:
None. (The Pevensie children deal with being grown, then suddenly being young again.)

Review:
Peter and Lucy confront the issue of memory.  In canon, when the Pevensies return as adults to the Western Wood and find the lamppost, they talk about War Drobe and Spare Oom - it used to strike me as odd that they'd confuse things like that, but I suppose it's not so odd really.  As an adult, Lucy couldn't remember her father (who had already been away fighting in the war for some time when the children were evacuated - this actually happened to a lot of young children and their fathers in Britain at the end of WWII) except from the stories Peter (whom a lot of the job of raising her had fallen to) tells her.  When they return through the wardrobe and suddenly become children again, suddenly remember the war and the housekeeper and that they'd come in here to hide, all the children are troubled, but Peter especially - he finds himself afraid that this time, he'll forget too.  That as he grows up again, he'll forget the people who were so important to him in Narnia.  This fic is understated, showing, hinting, without ever quite making it clear but in dealing with the issue of memory, its also unlike any of the other fics on the subject that I've read before and I think that's why its lovely.

Lives by Breaking (on Yuletide)
makoyi: (Default)
Title:  By Royal Decree
Author: [archiveofourown.org profile] rthstewart 
Fandom:  Narnia
Genre:  Philosophy
Length: Medium (Words: 44,155)

Author's Summary:
"A woman in a corset is a lie, a falsehood, a fiction, but for us, this fiction is better than the reality." A Golden Age tale of snark, sex, high finance, and tree pollen.

Review:
A bit more of the same for today.  Rthstewart again writes the Pevensies as philosophical statesmen.  Again, well written and well characterized.  Again, warnings that if you don't necessarily agree with the positions taken, you might not enjoy it as much but generally the characters are pretty diplomatic so you might not mind.

By Royal Decree (on AO3)
makoyi: (Default)
Title:  The Stone Gryphon
Author: [archiveofourown.org profile] rthstewart 
Fandom:  Narnia
Genre:  Missing Moments?/Continuation, Philosophy
Length: Epic (Words: 481,465)

Author's Summary:
1. In the summer of the Dawn Treader, Aslan tries to get Peter's attention. But, it's all Greek to Peter as he studies with Professor Kirke and meets unusual people, including a polygamous ethnologist, a spy, and a paleontologist with a passion for Alice's Adventures in Wonderland.

Review:
This fic is so well written.  The Pevensie children continually demonstrate that they are very competent statesmen indeed and make thoughtful/thought-provoking (but not preachy) discussions of weighty issues.  I knew by chapter 3 of the first part that it deserves the rec, it's that good.  A minor warning: this is a story containing philosophical debates and, as I've warned for parodies in the past, I'll just mention that if you strongly disagree with any of the positions taken, you may not enjoy this story as much as I have.  The Pevensies are very diplomatic, so I don't think it will be a huge problem for most people, but I'll just put that out there. 

Part of the reason I like it is that I enjoy the political, cultural, and philosophical discussions and their use in fiction is very difficult to do well but this fic manges that.  I also like the characters - not just the Pevensies, though they're very well done too; there are some very engaging OCs as well as good further development on Kirke and Eustace and his family.  Plus, at nearly half a million words, all that goodness just keeps coming... well actually, I should clarify that: it can get a bit tedious sometimes because this isn't always the action-packed, driven, page-turner of a story.  Its not the type of fic that has me plowing through 80k words in one sitting, but it is good for reading a chapter here and a chapter there between other fics or before bed or while waiting for the bus.  It's not a can't-put-it-down fic, but it is a fic you'd keep coming back to until you finish it and that's good, if a bit different from the other stories I tend to rec.

The Stone Gryphon (on AO3)
makoyi: (Default)
Title: Fairy Stories (Or, Three Men Susan Never Really Loved)
Author: [livejournal.com profile] animus_wyrmis [livejournal.com profile] animus_wyrmis 
Fandom: Narnia
Pairings: Mentions of Susan/Rabadash, Susan/Caspian, Susan/Geeky Kid (all unrequited)
Genre: Family/Friendship
Length:  Medium (Words: ~8k)

Author's Summary:
At St Finbarr’s, Susan tells the girls fairy stories before bed, and Lucy remembers how they really went. Susan/Rabadash, Susan/Caspian, Susan/Geeky Kid.

Review:
I like how this fic deals with the twisted chronology of the girls' lives and how it affects their growing up (even though I'm not sure it all adds up the same throughout the fic since sometimes it's "like a dream of a dream" and sometimes the girls recall very detailed stories).  Still, I like how this fic portrays the differences between Susan and Lucy and shows their relationship.  It's well written and I think the girls' voices are spot on for the movie!verse.

Fairy Stories [Or, Three Men Susan Never Really Loved] (on lj)
makoyi: (Default)
Title:  Went Forth Unconquered
Author:  [livejournal.com profile] gisho 
Fandom: Chronicles of Narnia
Pairings: None
Genre: General
Length:  Short

Author's Summary:
None given.

Review:
Susan has lost faith, but she doesn't doubt that what she knew was real (for a given value of real).

I like this story a lot.  It's dark and very anti-Aslan, but it's hopeful in a way too and Susan is empowered despite being forsaken.

Went Forth Unconquered (on lj)
makoyi: (Default)
Title: Carpetbaggers
Author:  [archiveofourown.org profile] cofax 
Fandom: Chronicles of Narnia
Pairings: None
Genre:
General
Length:  Long (Words: 119,268)

Author's Summary:
The day after Aslan left, taking the magic with him, just about everyone else left, too.

After the coronation festivities, the real work begins. During/post "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe".

Review:
I like this story because it's less perfect fairy tale without being less Narnia.  It's a very nice, thoughtful story, written in a similar style to canon.  It's just that the Pevensies' happy ending turns out to be only the beginning of a lot of hard work.

Carpetbaggers (on AO3)

makoyi: (Default)
Title: National Service
Author: [archiveofourown.org profile] burntcopper 
Fandom: Chronicles of Narnia
Genre: Post-series, War, Dark
Length: Medium (Words: ~8k = first 5 fics which are their own story arc and stand alone, then there's another 52k fic in the series about a concurrent but independent story arc featuring Susan as Torchwood agent which is rec'd in a separate post here)
Warnings: Violence
Admin Note: rec'd on fancake, rec'd on TV Tropes

Author's Summary:
1. Soldiering is soldiering, even when you're using a gun rather than a sword. And they're underestimating you because of your age.
2. Some lads stand out when they're called up.
3. You'd think one Pevensie in the military was enough.
4. Some people really don't understand the concept of playfighting.
5. No parent wants to know this about their children.

Review:
This is a seriously dark series and that's part of the reason I love it.  Narnia canon broke me a little because of the way Aslan (aka Jesus) treated Susan at the end, so most of the Narnia fics I like tend to be quite dark.  This one is one of the darkest and it couldn't be more different from canon, yet it works.  It's a fic that reminds you in detail that the best rulers are unpleasant people.  All four Pevensies came back from Narnia as medieval warrior-monarchs - because in Narnia, that was how they did wonderful, good things - but to the rest of the mundane world who doesn't understand how it happened or what purpose it could serve, they appear to be nearly sociopathic.  The characterization is chilling, at times, but I can't help but admire how capable the Pevensies are and how they work so closely together to navigate the mundane world that doesn't understand them.

National Service (on AO3)
podfics available (on AO3) by [archiveofourown.org profile] croissantkatie 

Profile

makoyi: (Default)
Makoyi